Search

personal finance

Bankruptcy Rate Drops in Canada

by Doug Hoyes

The bankruptcy rate in Canada dropped in 2010, according to statistics recently released by the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy. That’s good news, right? Yes and no.

First, let’s review the numbers. In 2010 a total of 135,008 Canadians filed a consumer proposal or personal bankruptcy. That’s an 11% drop from the 151,712 who filed in 2009. That’s a drop of 16,704 people, and yes, that’s good news. Fewer Canadians declared themselves insolvent in 2010. Now let’s take a look behind the numbers.

Personal Bankruptcy Rate Falls, By Consumer Proposals Increase Dramatically

Personal bankruptcies dropped from 116,381 to 92,694, a drop of over 20%. But consumer proposal filings increased by almost 20%, increasing from 35,331 to 42,314.

So why did personal bankruptcy filings drop, while consumer proposal filings increased? Two reasons:

First, the economy in Canada was somewhat better in 2010 than it was in early 2009, as we were still in “recovery mode” after the credit crisis and stock market correction in late 2008. A better economy generally means lower unemployment, higher consumer spending, and generally fewer personal bankruptcies. So it’s not surprising that the total number of insolvencies (bankruptcies and proposals) dropped, and that the number of personal bankruptcies also decreased significantly.

It’s also not surprising that, in a good economy, Canadians in debt are more likely to choose a proposal over bankruptcy if they can’t pay their bills. In a proposal you make a payment each month, and that money is distributed to your creditors. If you don’t have a job or a source of income, a proposal probably isn’t possible. If you are working and do have an income (just not enough to pay your bills in full), then a consumer proposal is a great solution. Clearly there is a greater chance of Canadians having jobs during good economic periods, so during recessions proposal filings are likely to drop, while in good times they may proportionately increase.

Second, the government changed the bankruptcy rules in 2009, making bankruptcy more expensive for Canadians with surplus income. As a result, in 2010 more Canadians chose to file a consumer proposal as a way to avoid bankruptcy.

So yes, it’s good news that bankruptcy numbers are down, but you have to take the numbers with “a grain of salt”, since part of the decrease in bankruptcy filings was due to a change in the rules.

Also, let’s not forget that debt in Canada remains a ticking time bomb, and massive credit card debt continues to lead to bankruptcy in Canada. Year to year bankruptcy numbers may rise and fall, but over the long term, as long as our debt remains high, Canadian will continue to file bankruptcy.

If you are interested in 2010 bankruptcy statistics for other areas of Canada, here’s list of other articles on bankruptcy statistics

If you are experiencing financial problems and think bankruptcy might be the answer, use our free debt options calculator to review your options, and then contact a licensed bankruptcy trustee today for a free initial consultation, and be sure to ask about a consumer proposal, the number one alternative to bankruptcy.

Posted on Monday, March 28th, 2011
Filed under: bankruptcy Canada
posted by Doug Hoyes @ 7:44 am No Comments

Massive Credit Card Debt Leads to Bankruptcy in Canada

by Doug Hoyes

Look in the mirror. It’s likely that you have more in common with the average person who files bankruptcy in Canada than you may think.

My name is Douglas Hoyes, a trustee with Hoyes, Michalos & Associates Inc. in Ontario, and today we released Joe Debtor, The Face of Bankruptcy, a comprehensive new research study profiling the average person who files a consumer proposal or bankruptcy in Ontario. We call this average person “Joe Debtor”.

Who is Joe Debtor? What does he look like?

Joe Debtor looks just like the average Canadian. He has a job, and may also own a home. He is very similar to the average person. The only difference between Joe Debtor and the average Canadian is that Joe Debtor has a huge amount of debt.

Here are some facts:

Comparison of Joe Debtor to Average Canadian
Personal Information:
Joe Debtor
Average Canadian
Male1 58% 49%
Female1 42% 51%
Average age2 41 41
Married or Common-law3 45% 52%
Divorced or Separated 26% 10%
Widowed 2% 6%
Single 27% 32%
Average family size3 2.3 2.6
Average monthly income4 $2,240 $2,419
Total credit card debt5 $24,390 $3,709
Total unsecured debt6 $59,814 $16,399

 

The Big Difference: Debt

Joe Debtor Debt Canada

Joe Debtor's Unsecured Debt

 

As you can see, the most significant difference between Joe Debtor and the average resident of Canada is debt. (That’s not surprising to readers of this blog; the most read post here on Trustees Talk is our post on Personal Debt in Canada: The Ticking Time Bomb.

The average Canadian has about $16,400 worth of consumer credit (debt excluding mortgages), while Joe Debtor has almost $60,000 in unsecured debt. That means that Joe Debtor has more than three and a half times as much debt, so it’s no surprise that Joe Debtor gets into financial trouble.

Simply put, debt is very dangerous.

To find out if you may have a debt problem, take this quick four question survey:

1 Are my debts, not including my mortgage, closer to the Canadian average of $16,400, or closer to Joe’s average of almost $60,000? If your debt is close to, or higher than $60,000, you owe more than Joe Debtor, and that’s an indicator that you may have a debt problem.

2 “Joe Debtor” owes $24,390 spread out over more than four credit cards. In other words, the typical bankrupt person in Canada has a lot of credit card debt. If you owe near that amount, and you are having trouble making your payments, you have a debt problem. If you are carrying a balance each month on any credit cards, you have a debt problem, because credit cards are the most expensive form of borrowing.

3 Am I afraid to open my mail? If you have bills that you haven’t opened because you know you can’t pay, you probably have a debt problem.

4 Am I “robbing Peter to pay Paul”? Do I take a cash advance from my line of credit to pay my credit card, and then next month will I take a cash advance from my credit card to make the minimum payment on my line of credit? If you are simply borrowing from one place to pay another, your debt, with interest, is gradually increasing, and you probably have a debt problem.

How can you solve your debt problem?

Start by taking inventory. Make a list of all of your debts, and the amount you owe. Make a budget to see where your money goes each month. If you can cut expenses and use the extra money to pay off your debts, great; that’s the perfect solution for you.

If you are like Joe Debtor and you have more debt than you can handle, consider filing a consumer proposal. You make one manageable monthly payment, and your unsecured debts are eliminated. If that’s not possible, filing bankruptcy in Canada may be your final option.

To find out more, use our free, on-line debt options calculator to review your options, then contact a consumer proposal administrator or bankruptcy trustee for a no-charge initial consultation.

 

1. Statistics Canada: Percentage of population over the age of 20, July 2010

2. Statistics Canada: Median age 2010

3. 2006 Census of Canada: Ontario

4. Statistics Canada: Personal Disposable Income per capita

5. Trans Union

6. Statistics Canada: Consumer Credit, Seasonally Adjusted per adult (18+)

Posted on Monday, February 28th, 2011
Filed under: bankruptcy Canada andConsumer Proposal andDebt Options
posted by Doug Hoyes @ 8:07 am No Comments

Power Spending – Getting More For Less

by Doug Hoyes

In addition to our articles bankruptcy in Canada, we occasionally review books that may be of interest to our readers. You can see all book reviews in our book review section.

Today we review Power Spending: Getting More For Less by Carolyn Johnston, Eric Poulin and Robin Poulin. I was consulted for the section of the book on debt, and bankruptcy, and in fact the Bankruptcy-Canada.ca website is referenced to describe how a consumer proposal works.

With that said, the highest compliment I can give this book is that it’s full of practical financial advice. Lot’s of book talk about theories, and explain complicated budgeting systems that no-one could ever implement in real life. That’s not a problem with this book; everyone who reads it will find dozens of practical tips they can implement in real life, immediately.

That doesn’t surprise me, because two of the authors, Eric and Robin Poulin, are the Co-Founders Calendar Budget - sign up for a free trial of CalendarBudget, the online personal finance tracking and planning tool that makes managing money easy. You simply open the program and you will see a calendar. Enter what you spent today in the calendar. That’s it! The program will then summarize where you spend your money, and help you produce easy to use graphs and charts so you can easily see where your money is going. (You can even get a free, one-month trial of Calendar Budget; after that, there is a very small cost each month).

Knowing that CalendarBudget is easy to use but also very powerful, I knew that Power Spending: Getting More For Less would also be powerful, but easy to apply and understand.

The first section starts with basic economic survival, and discusses household budgeting, emergency planning, credit and debt, and how to save money.

The second section is on Advanced Power Spending, and includes chapters on how to save money on your food bill (and since everyone eats, this should help everyone), and chapters on saving money on entertainment, travel, and even partying!

All chapters contain practical advice. Let me prove it. I opened the book randomly on five different pages; here’s a practical, easy to implement tip from each page I opened to:

  • put money aside at the beginning of the month (because if you wait until the end of the month, it won’t be there) (page 57);
  • on page 75 they have a nine step sidebar to answer the question “should I lease or buy a vehicle”; (the advice is practical, but you’ll have to buy the buy the book for the actual tips!;
  • don’t buy life insurance for your baby; the only members of your family who need life insurance coverage are those whose death would create a financial hardship (page 93);
  • on page 120 they have 19 ideas for an inexpensive date, including test driving cars, going on a picnic, and playing with animals at a pet shop;
  • on page 166 the book has six tips for how to sell stuff you no longer need by selling on-line.

As you can see, all of the tips are practical and easy to implement.

I suggest you start with the table of contents, and open the book at whatever section most appeals to you; you don’t have to, and probably won’t, read the book from cover to cover. Start where you want, use the tips, and return often for a refresher. That’s what makes Power Spending: Getting More For Less a powerful, practical book.

Posted on Monday, February 7th, 2011
Filed under: Book Reviews
posted by Doug Hoyes @ 5:31 am No Comments

Credit Education Week Canada, and the Language of Money

by Doug Hoyes

Why do Canadians have problems with money? Why do we have too much debt, and no savings? Obviously the prolonged recession has not helped, but I believe one of the reasons we get into financial trouble is that we simply don’t fully understand money, credit and debt. In Canada, financial education is not a priority in our schools, or for adults once they are out of school.

That’s why I think that Credit Education Week in Canada is a great idea. It’s one week in the year when we can take the time to focus on money, and educating ourselves about credit.

Credit Education Week Canada 2010 starts today, November 15, and runs for the week, until November 19, 2010. This year’s edition is Canada’s fourth annual Credit Education Week, and the focus this year is on newcomers, and the theme is The Language of Money.

That’s an interesting concept: The Language of Money. As a bankruptcy trustee in Canada, I am very aware of how we use language to describe money, and our financial situation.

Some words are complicated; people get confused with words like “creditor” and “debtor”, and there’s little doubt that that confusion makes it difficult for people to talk about money. We don’t want to admit that we don’t know what the big words mean, so we just don’t talk about it.

(For the record, a “creditor” is someone you owe money to, like a bank or credit card company. A “debtor” is you, the person who owes the money).

Some words are easy, but they have hidden meanings. For example, what is a credit card? That’s easy, you say. A credit card is something that we use to buy things; it gives us access to credit. We all know that credit is a good thing. We all know that you should “give credit where credit is due”. When someone does something good, we should give them credit for a job well done. Credit is good.

Of course a credit card is neither good nor bad. It’s an inanimate object; it’s just a hunk of plastic. It’s how you use it that makes it good or bad.

But that’s the hidden meaning: we use the word credit card to convince ourselves that credit is good.

What would happen if we called it a debt card. Calling it a debt card makes sense; when you buy something with plastic you are incurring debt. You now have a debt that you have to pay at the end of the month, and if you don’t you will pay interest.

See the difference words can make? Calling something a debt card educates us on what it really is, and what it really does.

So, this week, as you read about Credit Education Week in Canada, pay attention to the language you use to describe money. It may give you a new perspective on how money works, and it may make it easier for you to spend less, save more, and deal with your debt.

If you can’t attend any Credit Education Week events, then educate yourself on the various methods for dealing with debt, including:

  1. Pay off your debts on your own. Make a budget, cut your expenses, and pay off your debts yourself. This works well if you owe a manageable amount.
  2. If you can afford to pay off your debts in full, but just need a break on the interest, credit counselling is an option.
  3. If you can’t afford to pay off your debts in full, but you can afford to pay back something, a consumer proposal is a logical option. Most credit card companies will accept a reasonable consumer proposal.
  4. If you can’t afford a proposal, personal bankruptcy in Canada may be your final option.

Use our free debt options calculator to educate yourself on the various options for dealing with debt.

You have the power to educate yourself, so use Credit Education Week as your opportunity to educate yourself about credit and debt. It will be time well spent.

Posted on Monday, November 15th, 2010
Filed under: Debt Options
posted by Doug Hoyes @ 2:48 am No Comments

Why are More Seniors Filing Bankruptcy in Canada?

by Doug Hoyes

This week the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy released statistics stating that an increasing number of senior citizens are filing for bankruptcy in Canada. Here’s a quote from the report:

From 1989 to 2009, the proportion of insolvent consumers between 18 and 34 years of age has fallen steadily (from 12.9 percent to 4.4 percent among those 18 to 24 years of age and 43.0 percent to 22.3 percent among those 25 to 34 years of age). Over the same period, the proportion of insolvent consumers among older age groups has increased (from 11.3 percent to 24.7 percent among those 45 to 54 years of age and among those 55 years of age and above the proportion has more than quadrupled from 4.6 percent to 20.6 percent).

So why are more seniors declaring personal bankruptcy?

Doug Hoyes, Bankruptcy Trustee

Doug Hoyes, Bankruptcy Trustee

As a licensed bankruptcy trustee helping people file bankruptcy in Ontario, I have a number of thoughts on why the percentage of seniors filing bankruptcy is increasing.

First, as every resident of Canada is aware, we are in a recession. A recession hurts everyone. It’s possible that in the current economic downturn more seniors have lost their jobs, or had their incomes reduced, leading to serious financial problems. Often when a company needs to cut back, they cut their highest paid workers, which often are their older workers.

Second, a growing number of Canadians in their 40′s, 50′s and 60′s are carrying mortgages and other debts into retirement. Twenty or thirty years ago Canadians typically retired with little or no debt; they paid off their mortgage before they retired. That was possible because by the age of 65 most Canadians were able to pay off their debts.

However, today, it’s not uncommon to be laid off while you are still in your 40′s or 50′s, and if you are unable to find a similarly well paying job, you may be forced into early retirement before you are able to pay off your debts. That’s why it’s increasingly important to keep your debts as low as possible, in the event your job situation unexpectedly changes.

Third, many seniors assumed that their house or other real estate would be their “retirement fund.” They assumed that when their children were grown and they themselves retired they would sell their house and move to a smaller house, pocketing the difference. Unfortunately with the weak real estate market over the last two years house prices in many areas of Canada have declined, so seniors cannot sell their house for as much as they had hoped.

Finally, I meet with a significant number of seniors who were good money managers, and had little or no debt for most of their lives, but then they go into debt to help their adult children. If you are 60 years old with no debt and a paid off house, and your 30 year old son or daughter loses their job, and they have a young family to support, what do you do? Many parents help their children, and often they help them by re-mortgaging their house, or getting a line of credit. If your child is not able to pay you back, the senior, on a reduced income, is left with more debt than they can handle.

Does this mean you shouldn’t help your children or other friends and family when they have financial problems? No, if you want to help, you should, but it’s important to help with cash, and not to incur excessive debt to help others.

What’s the solution?

First, we should all strive to have little or no debt. You may not have a lot of savings when you retire, but if you retire with no debt you will probably be able to survive with your company and government pensions.

Second, seniors should be careful to only help others within their means; don’t risk bankruptcy for yourself by borrowing excessively to help others.

If you have more debt than you can handle, check out our free, interactive debt options calculator that calculates your different debt management options. It may be possible to work through your debts on your own, or perhaps file a consumer proposal to avoid bankruptcy, but professional advice is wise to fully explore your options.

Posted on Monday, October 18th, 2010
Filed under: Bankruptcy Alternatives andbankruptcy Canada andConsumer Proposal
posted by Doug Hoyes @ 5:34 am No Comments

Credit Cards: The Fast Route to Bankruptcy in Canada

by Doug Hoyes

What’s the fastest way to accumulate so much debt that you have no option but to file bankruptcy in Canada? As a bankruptcy trustee I have handled thousands of personal bankruptcy filings over the last two decades, and the answer to that question, based on my experience, is easy:

Douglas Hoyes, Bankruptcy Trustee

Credit cards.

If you want to get into serious financial trouble, excessive credit card debt is a sure fire way to invite financial disaster.

Two years ago my firm did a study of “Joe Debtor”, the average person who declares bankruptcy in Canada. Our study showed that 93% of Canadians that file personal bankruptcy or a consumer proposal have credit card debt, and the average they owed on their credit cards at the time of filing was just under $20,000. (With other debts, like taxes and lines of credit, the total unsecured debt was just over $50,000).

The facts are clear: it’s unlikely that someone with no credit card debt will have a need to file bankruptcy. The more credit card debt you have, the more likely it is that bankruptcy may be in your future. Why is that?

First, in the past, credit cards were easy to get. We all remember the “boom times” up to 2008, when many of us received numerous credit card offers in the mail each week. We were all “pre-approved” for a $10,000 gold, or platinum, credit card with a “low introductory” rate. Remember? You said “great, I can transfer my balance from my high interest rate card to the low rate card, and save money!” And you did.

But then your car broke down and you needed money for repairs, or you were off sick from work, or some other problem occurred and you needed money. You had unused credit on the credit card you just paid off, so you used it. But now, of course, you have a problem: instead of just owing money on one credit card, you are now carrying a balance on two cards. That puts you in a cash flow squeeze every month.

Then you realized that the “low introductory rate” was only temporary, and after six months your interest rate went way up, so now you are paying even more each month.

High interest rates are a problem, but for most people who declare bankruptcy their financial problems became critical when something happened in their lives: job loss, a marriage break up, or perhaps a health issue that caused them to miss work and led to reduced income.

It’s now 2010, and ever since the “credit crisis” of 2008 the flow of credit card offers in our mailboxes has slowed to a trickle, or disappeared entirely. The days of easy access to credit are over, at least for now.

Even more challenging for Canadians with credit card debts is the reality that credit card issuers are tightening up their credit requirements. Based on the stories I have heard over the last few weeks from the dozens of people in debt I meet with each week, it appears that the credit card issuers are in the process of “culling” their credit card portfolios. They are identifying higher risk clients, and raising their interest rates to encourage them to go elsewhere. Here’s a typical story from a lady I met with this week, with her name changed to protect her privacy:

Jane is single, and has carried a large balance on her ABC Credit Card for many years. Over the years ABC has gradually increased her credit limit, and for many years they offered her what she believed was an attractive interest rate of 9.9%. Her minimum payment was about $430 per month, which was manageable based on her income. Last week she got her monthly statement, and the minimum required payment was increased to $750 per month.

She assumed that it was a mistake, so she called ABC Credit Card Company, and they advised her that no, it was not a mistake. Due to changes by the “regulatory board” her interest rate was now much higher, resulting in a higher minimum monthly payment.

When I met with her I explained that I had never heard of the “regulatory board” (although I am familiar with the new credit card regulations), but it’s easy to see what the credit card company is doing. The balance owing on her credit card was over $20,000; it is by far her largest debt. On her current income it is unlikely that she will ever be able to repay the debt. The credit card company realizes this, so they are attempting to get rid of her as a client before she defaults on the amount owing. Their hope is that her credit is still good enough to allow her to borrow from someone else, and repay them.

Unfortunately for Jane, she has no assets to pledge as collateral for a loan, and she has no family members that are able to co-sign for a loan. Based on a review of her situation, she decided that her best option is to file a consumer proposal, where she will offer her creditors approximately a third of the full amount owing, to be paid over the next four years (the amount offered varies based on your income and financial situation). With a consumer proposal Jane will no longer have any credit cards, and her credit score is damaged, but she will have a manageable monthly payment, and in four years (or less) she will be out of debt. For Jane, it’s the correct solution.

Is it the correct solution for the credit card company? It could be argued that they would be better off had they not raised her interest rate; she would have continued to muddle along, and they make have collected more money over the next few years. However, they decided that they wanted to reduce their risk, so Jane responded by filing a consumer proposal.

If you want to be proactive and deal with your credit card debt before your credit card company raises your rates, check out our free, interactive debt options calculator that tells you what it will cost to deal with your debts. The sooner you take action, the sooner you will be free of high credit card interest rates.

Posted on Monday, September 27th, 2010
Filed under: bankruptcy Canada andConsumer Proposal andDebt Options
posted by Doug Hoyes @ 3:15 am No Comments

Credit Cards: Why The New Rules May Not Be Good News For You

by Doug Hoyes

Doug Hoyes, Bankruptcy Trustee

Doug Hoyes, Bankruptcy Trustee

On September 1, 2010 new credit card regulations took effect in Canada. What are the new rules, and what will they mean to you? Here are the three new regulations:

The New Credit Card Regulations in Canada

First, credit card issuers must offer a minimum 21 day grace period, during which they can’t charge you interest on new credit card purchases, provided you pay off your balance in full by the due dated. Under the old regulations grace periods varied, and the card issuer could charge interest on purchases from the date of the purchase if you had not paid last month’s bill in full.

Second, when you make a payment on your credit card above the minimum amount, that payment must be applied to the balance with the highest interest rate first, or proportionally to all transactions. Under the previous regulations credit card issuers could apply payments however they wanted, such as applying payments to the lower interest balances, resulting in higher interest payments.

Third, your monthly credit card statement will be easier to understand, and must include disclosure of how long it will take you to pay off a balance if you only make the minimum payment. They must also give you advance notice if they are increasing your interest rate.

What The New Credit Card Rules Mean for You

On the surface, these new regulations appear to be good news for consumers. You are now guaranteed a 21 day grace period when you make a purchase on a credit card, so if you pay your balance in full at the end of the month, you now have a 21 day interest free loan. Your payments will be applied to your highest interest rate balances, which may reduce the interest you pay, and you will be notified of interest rate changes in advance.

But a closer review of the new rules reveals that this may not be a good news story for you.

First, as reported in the Globe and Mail, when similar regulations were introduced in the United States, card issuers responded by raising the interest rates they charge. Whether or not that will occur in Canada remains to be seen, but it’s easy to see why it happened: if the credit card issuer is making less money due to a longer interest free grace period, they can recover that lost income by raising the interest rates they charge. So, in the end, consumers may not benefit from the new rules.

But there is an even greater reason why these new rules are not good news for you:

You should not be paying interest on credit cards!

Credit cards are a very expensive way to borrow. A “low interest” credit card may have an interest rate of 12%; a standard card has an interest rate of 19%, and a department store or gas company card may have interest rates of 25% or higher. Contrast that with mortgage rates in Canada of around 5%, and you can see that credit card interest rates are very high. And yes, I realize that a mortgage is a loan secured by real estate, and therefore will carry a lower interest rate than an unsecured credit card balance, but even a comparison to loan rates charged by banks for unsecured lines of credit will show that credit cards have very high interest rates.

As consumers, we pay for convenience. A credit card is very convenient. Swipe it, and you’re done. But you are paying a huge price for that convenience.

So here is my new credit card rule, that you can implement for yourself, immediately, today:

Do not carry a balance on your credit cards.

That’s it. It’s a simple rule, and it means you will never pay another cent in high credit card interest.

If you must borrow, borrow at lower rates by getting a home equity debt consolidation loan (if you own a house), or a debt consolidation loan at a lower interest rate, and save money.

What do you do if you can’t qualify for a debt consolidation loan? What can you do if you owe so much on your credit cards that the bank won’t lend you money to pay off your credit cards? You have a few choices:

  1. Pay off your debts on your own. Make a budget, cut your expenses, and pay off your debts yourself. This works well if you owe a manageable amount.
  2. If you can afford to pay off your debts in full, but just need a break on the interest, credit counselling is an option.
  3. If you can’t afford to pay off your debts in full, but you can afford to pay back something, a consumer proposal is a logical option. Most credit card companies will accept a reasonable consumer proposal.
  4. If you can’t afford a proposal, personal bankruptcy in Canada may be your final option.

Use our free debt options calculator to review your options.

Don’t be fooled into believing that the new credit card regulations will help you. The best credit card debt is no credit card debt, so make a plan today to eliminate your credit card debt, because with no debt you don’t need to worry about grace periods or interest rates. Be debt free.

Posted on Monday, September 6th, 2010
Filed under: Bankruptcy Alternatives andbankruptcy Canada andConsumer Proposal andDebt Options
posted by Doug Hoyes @ 4:27 am No Comments

Debt Settlement Plans

by Ted Michalos

I have written quite a few pieces were I am critical of the “debt consulting” industry and persons presenting themselves as credit counsellors when they have little or no formal education or credentials. It’s not that I begrudge any of these people a livelihood – I just wish they’d pick a career that doesn’t involve gouging an already desperate portion of the population.

Ted Michalos, Bankruptcy Trustee

Ted Michalos, Bankruptcy Trustee

If you are unfamiliar with the term debt settlement it generally means some sort of negotiated deal to repay a portion of your debt. The service is real – most creditors will accept a partial repayment, particularly in a lump sum, once your debt has gone into collections. The trick here is one of timing. The debt settlement companies charge an upfront fee plus a percentage of the settled debt. They pay themselves first before they actually settle with your creditors and they can’t settle with your creditors until they have “saved up” enough of your payments to offer a deal.

That’s a bit confusing, so an example might help. Let’s say you owe $50,000 on your credit cards. The debt settlement company tells you they can settle with your creditors for $25,000. The upfront fee is $2,000 and they’ll charge another 20% of the settled amount – $5,000. Let’s say you agree to $1,000 a month. So the first 7 months will go to pay them and then your payments will go into a savings account until they accumulate enough to offer one of your creditors the 50% deal. During this time you have no legal protection and in many cases the creditors simply proceed to collections and then take legal action against you. To stop the legal action you end up filing a consumer proposal or perhaps bankruptcy (of course you won’t get any of the money back from the debt settlement company).

An alternative might be a consumer proposal whereby you offer the same settlement (50%), but it would play out quite differently. A consumer proposal can be spread over five years which would give you a much lower payment. Just to keep the comparison similar though, we’ll say you can pay the $1,000 per month. Your proposal will run for 25 months (the debt settlement plan would run for 32 assuming the creditors don’t cut it short). By law, the fees for the trustee are taken directly from the settlement; they are not added on top. In addition, after the preparation fee has been paid, $1,500, a trustee only receives payment when the creditors are paid – not in advance. Further, all of the creditors receive payments at the same time – you don’t settle with one, then save up and settle with the next. Most importantly, if you file a proposal you have legal protection from wage garnishees, collection agents and other legal actions.

If you’ve responded to a debt settlement ad and/or are actively considering this solution for your financial difficulties please make certain you understand the process that the company you will be dealing with is going to follow. As long as you understand the risks and the pitfalls of a debt settlement plan then you can add itn to the list of options to deal with your debts. Most people don’t take the time to “read the fine print” and as such go into these plans with high expectations only to have their creditors continue to pursue them, including collection actions and wage garnishees.

Be careful and consider all of your options before you sign.

Posted on Monday, August 16th, 2010
Filed under: Bankruptcy Alternatives andDebt Options
posted by Ted Michalos @ 4:08 am No Comments

Debt-Free Forever: A No-Nonsense Book Review

by Doug Hoyes

In addition to our usual commentary on bankruptcy in Canada, we occasionally review books that may be of interest to our readers. You can see all book reviews in our book review section.

Today we review Debt Free Forever: Take Control Of Your Money And Your Life by Gail Vaz-Oxlade, the host of TV’s Til Debt Do Us Part.

Gail Vaz-Oxlade's Debt Free Forever: Take Control Of Your Money And Your Life

I must confess that I am biased, because I have appeared twice on Till Debt Do Us Part as an “expert”. My first appearance was back on Episode #36, that first aired in 2007, called Single Mom Shake Up. My job was to explain the bankruptcy option to Tammy, the person featured on that episode. She was able to cut her expenses, and with the support of her family she avoided bankruptcy.

I also appeared in Season 8, on episode number 103; you can watch the entire episode on the Till Debt Do Us Part section of the Slice web site. (Warning: This is a very emotional episode; I had to give some difficult advice, as did Ms. Vaz-Oxlade; sometimes our advice is not taken, and that’s a difficult reality when you are a professional advisor).

As anyone who was watched Till Debt Do Us Part will know, Gail Vaz-Oxlade has a very “no nonsense” approach to money problems. She strongly believes that ultimately you are responsible for your behavior, so only you can change your behavior to eliminate money problems. I like that approach.

That no-nonsense approach is easy to see in Debt Free Forever: Take Control Of Your Money And Your Life as Gail Vaz-Oxlade starts at the same place I start in every meeting I have with someone in financial trouble: Figure Out Where You Stand. She gives practical tips on how to analyze your spending, and, most importantly, how to face up to your debt.

In my experience facing up to your debt is the hardest step to take in your journey to financial freedom. It’s hard to make a list of all of the money you owe, but it’s absolutely essential if you want to go on the next step, which is Part Two of the book: Make a Plan.

Doug Hoyes, Bankruptcy Trustee, Appearing on 'Til Debt Do Us Part

Her advice is always practical; you don’t need a math degree to follow her advice. She keeps it simple, using her trademark “jar” method of saving, where you put cash in your food jar, gas money jar, and so on to keep budgeting simple.

Speaking of budgeting, that’s Chapter 4, Create a Budget That Balances. Again, Gail gives practical advice on how to create a household budget, and how to cut expenses to make your budget balance. She illustrates the concept with what she calls the “Life Pie”, where money is allocated to life’s expenses, and you have to learn to divide the pie up to keep your spending in check.

While Debt Free Forever: Take Control Of Your Money And Your Life focuses on budgeting, spending control, and setting goals, Chapter 11 does deal with subject matter near and dear to my heart: Cope When the Caca Hits the Fan. She starts the chapter off by telling it like it is:

One of life’s hard truths is that it doesn’t matter how carefully you plan, how hard you work, or how diligent you are in taking care of the details, crap happens!….It’s nice to think that life is predictable, but it’s not ………Having made a budget, made a debt repayment plan, made up your mind to live your life consciously and take care of your money, you may dream that it’ll be smooth sailing from here on in, but it is only a dream. Sometimes life sucks.

Yes, I couldn’t agree more. Every day I meet with Canadians who were doing well, but then they got sick, lost their job, got divorced, or had some other tragedy derail their dream of financial independence. Sometimes, stuff happens. Fortunately, Gail Vaz-Oxlade carries her “no-nonsense” approach to the discussion of bankruptcy in Canada as well. Here’s what she has to say:

Bankruptcy isn’t the worst thing in the world. Living in the hell you’ve created is….

For many people, the decision to go bankrupt isn’t an easy one to make. It’s a thorny path. But if that’s what it’ll take to get you out of hell, then do it.

Wow. No-one will ever accuse Ms. Vaz-Oxlade of “sugar coating” her opinions. She’s right: in my experience it takes the average person six months of soul-searching before deciding to file bankruptcy. Bankruptcy is a last resort for dealing with your debts, but sometimes it is necessary.

If you are looking for a book that contains practical, easy to understand advice, Debt Free Forever: Take Control Of Your Money And Your Life is just what you are looking for. The advice is easy to understand, but it’s not easy to implement. Making change is hard, and it takes sacrifice, but if you are up the challenge, this book can help.

Posted on Monday, August 9th, 2010
Filed under: bankruptcy Canada andBook Reviews
posted by Doug Hoyes @ 2:05 am No Comments

Consumer Proposal: One of the most important financial tools available to Canadians

by Barton Goth

The consumer proposal is probably the least known of the processes to deal with overwhelming debt, but it is the mechanism that has the greatest capacity for good given our current economic environment. Let’s face it, right now the number one biggest risk to the Canadian economy isn’t the high dollar, it isn’t our level of productivity, it isn’t the strength of our largest trading partner – it is the state of our personal finances.

Barton Goth, Bankruptcy Trustee

After that bold statement I must insert my disclosure. My name is Barton Goth, I am a licensed Trustee in Bankruptcy and Consumer Proposal Administrator here in Edmonton. So I definitely have a bias. However, this statement is not made based solely on observations made in my daily practice, but based on the current state of our overall economy. Let us review:

• During the 2000s, the average Canadian’s asset growth was less than half the pace of the 1990’s and the growth in debt was twice as rapid (Roger Suave, The Current State of Family Finances 2009)

• In recent years household debt has surged three time faster than income and now stands at a record high of more than $1-trillion (Canada’s Brewing Debt Storm, The Globe and Mail Apr. 16, 2010, by Paul Waldie and Steve Ladurantaye)

• The average Canadian owes about $1.47 for every dollar of disposable income (Certified General Accountants Association of Canada, CIBC Economics, National Bank economics and Statistics Canada)

• For many years, debt was rising about 2.5 percentage points faster per year than income, this gap had widened to 4 to 5 percentage points by 2005 and rising by approximately 9 per cent in 2008. (Defusing Canada’s debt bomb, Globe and Mail Apr. 17, 2010, by Don Drummond, Chief economist, TD Bank Financial Group)

As a result of these alarming trends I think the traditional focus of our finances is going to have to move away from the saving and investment side of things, and toward dealing with the debt that more and more people are becoming burdened by. This is why a consumer proposal currently is one of the most important financial tools available to Canadian families. It is a tool that gives Canadians the ability to regain control of their finances before they are forced to consider a bankruptcy. As a result, I predict that we will continue to see a major increase in the number of proposals filed as people begin to realize the gravity of their financial position and begin to investigate what can been done to resolve these difficulties.

For those of you unfamiliar with consumer proposals, you are not alone. The idea of a consumer proposal is relatively new (first introduced into the Canadian insolvency legislation in 1992), but has provided a way for many Canadians over the years with a middle of the road option that contains many of the advantages associated with a bankruptcy, while avoiding some of the more significant disadvantages. A consumer proposal is especially advantageous for those people who cannot afford to pay their debts in full but have enough money coming in each month that realistically they should not be forced into the filing of a bankruptcy, a reality that an increasing number of Canadians are faced with each day.

The consumer proposal is one of the options available through the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act that provides a court sanctioned way to negotiate a settlement with your unsecured creditors (i.e. credit cards, personal loans, taxes etc.). There are many advantages to filing a consumer proposal. For instance, in a proposal you do not automatically lose any of your assets as you would in a bankruptcy. You are able to have a reduced impact on your credit over the long term than filing bankruptcy, and most importantly, you are able to bring the payments on your existing debt to a manageable level that will fit in your budget. At the same time, because the consumer proposal is a court sanctioned settlement, you only need a majority of your creditors to cooperate with the proposal and you benefit from court protection which mandates that all your unsecured creditors must participate in the proposal and can no longer collect on or charge any interest on these debts.

At a time when the average family is faced with waning savings, growing debt, aggressive lending practices and an uncertain economy, the consumer proposal may prove to be one of the most needed of all financial tools, and one that will assist many families in an effort to regain control of their finances and truly put their house in order.

If your one of the many Canadians who are currently struggling with your finances I have one word of advice, act now and schedule a time to review your finances with a consumer proposal administrator . If you are proactive, rather than reactive, you will be able to catch things early. The earlier you recognize the difficulties you face and the earlier you act, the more likely you will be able to qualify to file a consumer proposals and the quicker you will be able to regain control of your finances.

Posted on Monday, August 2nd, 2010
Filed under: Consumer Proposal andDebt Options
posted by Barton Goth @ 5:26 am No Comments

← Previous Entries